By Patrick Nease, Net Zero Manager, Meta

Carbon market participants are no strangers to shifting tides. From the explosion of the voluntary market over the last decade, to increased public scrutiny of project malpractice and ever-evolving standards for what “counts” toward climate goals, change comes with the territory. Still, an unwavering focus toward project quality and rigor has defined the last several years in the market. Organizations like the Integrity Council for the Voluntary Carbon Market have established principles that provide a benchmark for project quality. Project developers are increasingly incorporating remote sensing technologies and cutting-edge datasets to inform carbon measurement, reporting, and verification. Meanwhile, buyers’ diligence processes have matured, and pooled corporate demand is advancing high-integrity projects. As a result, buyers are signaling their demand for projects that raise the bar on quality, from prioritizing Indigenous leadership to advancing ecological restoration and more.

As new methodologies and project types get added to our toolkit to address the climate crisis, it seems like carbon market participants must broaden their expertise daily. It’s a daunting task to keep up with the latest international policy developments, updates to allometric equations that calculate forest carbon, and carbon capture technologies that might have been more familiar as a plot device in a sci-fi epic just a few years ago. 

Now, offshore geological basins are an increasingly favored option for storing captured CO2, with offshore storage hubs already operating in the North Sea and the Mediterranean. Should buyers now become experts in subsea geologic monitoring and the acoustic methods to do so? Should they seek to understand all of the potential impacts on fisheries or the various whale species that traverse these seas?

Today, Beyond is sharing Recommendations for Offshore CO₂ Storage, authored by experts from Chlorophyll, the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO), Meta, Northern Lights, and the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution. It assesses the potential environmental and social impacts of offshore CO2 storage, recommends practical safeguards, and provides a checklist for buyers and project developers to consider as these projects come online. These recommendations build on existing regulatory frameworks and standards, complementing the ongoing work across the market to accelerate the supply of carefully designed, high-quality carbon projects. 

Why we’re sharing this paper

The International Panel on Climate Change identifies carbon removal as a key lever to limit warming. Meanwhile, investors increasingly see subsurface geological basins as a pathway to durable carbon storage at scale. Offshore storage can serve Direct Air Capture, Bioenergy with Carbon Capture and Storage, and carbon captured from operations such as natural gas plants. Many offshore CO2 storage hubs leverage existing infrastructure from the oil and gas industry, and often see fewer permitting challenges compared to onshore storage, lowering near-term investment hurdles.

Yet as both private and public sector actors begin investing in these projects, we found few studies describing the risks associated with subsea CO2 leakage and relevant geological monitoring. Literature describing harmful impacts to wildlife or to the livelihoods of people that rely on these marine ecosystems exists, but is often highly localized or focused on offshore oil and gas operations. 

With investment growing and regulatory and voluntary frameworks still developing, now is a pivotal moment to shape offshore storage approaches. We’re sharing this paper to invite buyers, developers, standards organizations, and others to become familiar with the risks and explore opportunities to improve outcomes. This includes an expansion of familiar processes, such as robust carbon monitoring plans, and increasing understanding of emerging technologies, such as passive seismic monitoring that reduces sonic pollution harmful to whales and other wildlife.

No single sector could have developed these recommendations alone. The authors include carbon removal experts, marine and geoscientists, a corporate buyer, and an offshore storage operator. Their insights build upon existing frameworks and lessons from commercial and scientific communities.

Findings and Recommendations

Key takeaways in our report for all actors to consider include:

  1. Offshore storage projects are highly site-specific
    Geological basins and adjacent marine environments differ from one ecosystem to the next. A subsurface assessment, understanding of impacts to the environment and local communities, and monitoring plans must be tailored for each site. Buyers and developers can foster cross-sector collaboration by sharing both site-specific and general lessons.
  2. Existing and developing regulations provide a foundation for improving outcomes and minimizing potential negative impacts
    Existing offshore storage regulatory frameworks generally require site-specific operations plans, impact assessments, demonstration of financial accountability, and robust environmental monitoring. Buyers and developers can build on these to mitigate risks and improve social and environmental outcomes. In countries and offshore locations where regulatory schemes do not yet exist, national frameworks may shape the development of regulations and should be informed by considerations found in this report. 
  3. Several factors contribute to safe CO2 storage
    Site-specific considerations for safe carbon sequestration include operational expertise and accountability, subsurface physical and chemical processes, risk and impact assessments, and risk-optimized monitoring. Sound project management of these factors in collaboration with regulatory, community, and other offshore storage stakeholders can ensure safe operations.
  4. Field-testing low-impact, risk-optimized monitoring technologies and approaches will advance project design with effective safeguards
    Emerging CO2 and environmental monitoring techniques should be tested in field trials, preferably in commercial offshore storage project settings alongside the deployment of proven techniques. These approaches may reduce environmental and social risks while optimizing costs for operators.

We also invite readers to use the recommendations checklist provided in this report and share feedback to evolve safeguards and improve approaches to project management. As offshore CO2 projects become operational and inform the collective knowledge base, all relevant actors should consider their roles in shaping those projects and explore opportunities to share lessons with others. 

As approaches like offshore storage become more prevalent, we cannot expect every market participant to become an expert on active seismic monitoring’s effects on marine mammals, or the ideal geological basins for carbon sequestration. However, we hope the questions raised by this paper can inform safer project design and advance regulatory frameworks that reflect the latest scientific guidance.

By following these recommendations, participants can accelerate the adoption of safer approaches to carbon sequestration and raise the bar for projects that mitigate risks and improve outcomes for people and our oceans.

Download the full paper.

This report was funded by Meta and reviewed by Beyond. Its findings and recommendations do not necessarily reflect the viewpoints of Beyond, its members, or the organizations of the report’s authors.